Skip to main content

Alan Paton’s 3 Freedom Narratives and the Hypocrisies of Supremacy Laws


Table of Contents

Alan Stewart Paton was born on January 11, 1903, in Pietermaritzburg, Natal, South Africa. He was married to Dorrie Francis Lusted from 1928-1967. He attended the University of Natal and Maritzburg College.

Alan visited Norway and developed his ideas about his first novel Cry, the Beloved Country which was completed while in San Francisco in 1946. His debut novel, Cry, the Beloved Country was published in 1948 and became famous as a result of that.

Cry, the Beloved Country tells a story of racial injustice and profiling in the then apartheid South Africa. The novel later became the Liberal Party’s manifesto in 1953 of which Alan was a founding vice president. The party fought against the apartheid laws legislated by the National Party government. In 1949 Alan Paton received Anisfield-Wolf Book Awards. 

Alan’s first novel, Cry, the Beloved Country, his second, Too Late the Phalarope and his third, Ah, but Your Land is Beautiful will be viewed as his three freedom narratives as well as his contempt for apartheid and the hypocrisies of supremacy laws in then South Africa.

Cry, the Beloved Country

It tells tales of groups’ protests because of the way their society was structured, and people were profiled because of their colour. That put a great divide between white and black people in South Africa. Cry, the Beloved Country was not only a gripping narrative of the situation of events, but it was also a strong literary protest of systemic injustices (social, racial, tribal) on both sides, that is white and black peoples alike. For Paton, the black people of South Africa were affected by the community and moral displacements resulting from the diminishing tribal structures, and the white people were overwhelmed by ‘native crimes.’ 

The characters in the novel portray the impressions and lived experiences of Paton in Cry, the Beloved Country. For example, the character of The Girl (Absalom’s wife). She was depicted as a teenager, about 16 years old. According to Paton, the girl claimed that at 16 years old, Absalom was her third husband. Though we do not know the timeline of the marriages to the previous husbands, we can conjecture that perhaps, a year might be the interval between each husband.

Absalom was characterized as the son of a preacher (a priest), who went in search of his aunt, Gertrude in Johannesburg. Absalom later murdered Arthur Jarvis, who was the son of James Jarvis, a wealthy landowner.

Gertrude, the preacher’s sister was a prostitute in Johannesburg. Not minding his position as a preacher, Stephen went in search of his sister, Gertrude and son, Absalom in Johannesburg. 

Too Late the Phalarope

Too Late the Phalarope is the second novel by Alan Paton and was published in 1953. The title of the novel is connected to the bird known as the phalarope.

The phalaropes are shore birds found in Africa, Asia, the Americas, and Europe, which means the birds are virtually on every continent. The birds are notable for their special feeding method and nesting behaviour. A phalarope belongs to any of the three living species of slender-necked shorebirds of the bird family known as Scolopacidae.

In terms of reproduction, these birds practised what has been called sexual dimorphism. We know that ‘dimorphism’ is the existence of two different formations or appearances of a species in the same population. Then sexual morphism could be viewed as the existence of something in two different forms or appearances. The phalaropes are noted for their polyandrous behaviours, where one female has multiple male mates and vice versa.

We can imagine the reason Paton added the bird, the phalarope as part of the title of his second novel.  

Too Late the Phalarope tells the tale of an Afrikaner, Pieter van Vlaanderen, a South African police officer at crossroads between his convictions about the immorality of the apartheid laws and upholding the office as a man-of-order in South African society. In this story, Paton carried his campaign against apartheid to the law and its enforcement, to morality and norms, and to white supremacy in South Africa.  

The novel highlights the efficacy and ignominy of the ‘Immorality Act of 1927.’ The Act prohibits relationships between black and white people. Among the salient points of the novel was when Smith (a white man) slept with a black maid and she became pregnant. Because of shame and fear of breaking the ‘Immorality Act,’ Smith killed his maid and dismembered her body to hide the evidence.

The police officer himself, Pieter fell in love with a black woman, Stephanie, and had numerous sexual intercourse with her while at the same time upholding the ‘Immorality Act.’ At that point, Paton painted pictures of hypocrisies, the ignominy of the law, and the “phalarope complex.” Presumably, the ‘Immorality Act’ was meant to prevent black South Africans from meeting with white South Africans. Eventually, it was the white South Africans who sought out black South African women for sex.

Ah, but Your Land is Beautiful

Paton’s third novel, Ah, but Your Land is Beautiful was published in 1983. The work is a mix of life events and imagined circumstances. It consists of six sections.

Paton paints a picture of violent conflicts, ire, and seething bitterness between black, white, Indian, and mixed-race peoples.

Section one is about the Defiance Campaign in 1952 which was significant because of the action of an Indian youngster, Prem Bodasingh, who used the Durban Municipal Reference Library reserved for white people. She continually used the library and urged others to do the same as a way of protesting the apartheid laws. One could argue that this teenager’s action in 1952 might have influenced Rosa Parks in the USA. Rosa Parks refused to give up her seat to a white man on a Montgomery, Alabama bus in 1955. 

In section two, Paton reveals the predicaments of those who resent the apartheid regimes and laws. 

The ruling apartheid Nationalist government enforced apartheid laws and defaulters were penalized by loss of jobs and other benefits.

Paton, in section three, brings to the fore the tensions between the progenitors of Dutch colonists and English-speaking colonists and argues that it was the reason for the Boer War of the mid-19th century. He also pinpoints the apartheid as a point of divergence between the Anglican Church and the Afrikaner’s Calvinism (who were in support of apartheid).

In section four, Paton tells the influence and popularity of an Afrikaner, Jan Woldemade Fischer, a politician, and religious leader. As a part of the justice system, he trumpeted the apartheid system and was liked by the learned community as well as politicians and church leaders.

Nevertheless, he was brought down by a black South African whom he had an affair with thereby breaking the ‘Immorality Acts.’ He was convicted and sentenced to death. But he beat the system by committing suicide.

Section five is the point Paton commends the good works and life of those who remained docile, humane, and charitable, notwithstanding the apartheid laws. At the same time, he brings to light many crimes perpetrated by all concerned in South African societies.

In the final section, Paton sheds light on the political changes happening in South Africa. A vision for a better South Africa, that is peaceful, beautiful, and bright. 

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

The Connection between a Personal Name and Name Groups in Shawnee Social Organisation

Table of Contents Shawnee People The Divisions The Name Groups and Personal Names I’m always attracted to and interested in the culturally distinct and characteristic elements of different traditions or societies. Reading about the Shawnee people of Native American tribes is no different. I immediately fell in love with the linkage between Shawnee name groups and personal names. The name groups seem to present the Shawnee as a one-descent group with five major divisions. To examine this connection between a personal name and name group, a brief description of Shawnee will help in understanding the Shawnee social organisation. Shawnee People The term ‘Shawnee’ written in different forms ( Shaawanwaki, Shaawanowi lenaweeki, and Shawano ) is Algonquian like the archaic term ‘ shaawanwa ’ meaning ‘south.’ Thus, the term ‘Shawnee’ is (pronounced shaw-nee ) meaning the ‘southern people.’ The Shawnees are categorised as Algonquian-speaking North American Indian people whose pristine ho...

The Grammar of Governance: Re-Writing Nigeria through the Paradigm of "Obi"

Language has a way of mirroring the soul of a nation. When a political culture becomes corrupt, its vocabulary is the first thing to rot. For decades, the grammar of Nigerian politics has been defined by heavy, passive constructions, bloated adjectives of unearned titles, and verbs dedicated entirely to consumption: to share, to capture, to place-hold. The language of the state has become alien to the realities of the street. To salvage a broken nation, one must first salvage its syntax. This essay proposes a fundamental re-grammatisation of the Nigerian consciousness. It explores an alternative political paradigm not merely through a person, but through a linguistic shift, using the life, philosophy, and administrative antecedents of Mr. Peter Obi. By examining "Obi" as a complete grammatical ecosystem: spanning the Noun, Verb, Adjective, Adverb, and Gerund, we can map out a structural blueprint for a functional, accountable, and unified New Nigeria. Obi as a Noun: The ...

The Unblended Confluence: Metaphor, Myth, and the Reality of the Nigerian State

In the heart of Nigeria, at a geographical crossroads named Lokoja, a striking phenomenon unfolds. The River Niger: massive, slow-moving, and dark with the silt of its long journey from the Fouta Djallon highlands meets the River Benue, which flows fast, wide, and greenish blue from the Cameroonian mountains. They collide, poured into a single, massive basin. Yet, as any traveller looking down from the hills of Patti can see, they do not immediately mix. For miles downstream, a sharp, liquid frontier remains visible. Two distinct colours, two unique temperatures, and two parallel histories run side-by-side within the exact same banks. This geographic reality provides a razor-sharp metaphor for the socio-political architecture of modern Nigeria. Poured into a single administrative channel by the British Amalgamation of 1914, Nigeria’s over 250 ethnic nationalities have lived, traded, and flooded together for over a century. Yet, like the waters at Lokoja, they have never truly blended...

Assets Recovery: Investigating and Litigating Nigeria’s Political Leaders – Corruptio Optima, Pessima!

Introduction Nigeria’s political discourse is saturated with promises of “a new Nigeria,” yet the country remains trapped in cycles of corruption, elite impunity, and institutional decay. The contradiction is glaring: how can a nation be rebuilt by the very political class that has historically undermined its foundations? This paradox is captured in the ancient warning corruptio optima, pessima; when the best, the entrusted, the powerful become corrupt, their corruption is the worst of all. The central argument of this essay is straightforward: Nigeria cannot be rebuilt without a systematic investigation and litigation of political corruption, past and present. Any reform agenda that ignores this foundational requirement risks becoming a pretext for recycling and upgrading the same corrupt elite into a more sophisticated class of impunity. The Architecture of Corruption in Nigeria Nigeria’s corruption is not random; it is structural. It operates through: Elite capture...

Names, Visions, and Imageries of the Crow tribe of Native Americans

Table of Contents The Crow: Who are they? Names, Visions, and Imageries Apsaalooke (or Absaroka) The Separations of the Bands The Mountain Crow (Ashalaho) The River Crow The Kicked in the Bellies Chiefs, Their Names and Meanings Chief Long Hair (Issheuhutskitu) Chief Sore Belly (Arapoosh) Chief of the Camp (Ashbacheeitche) Chief of Plenty Coups The rich cultural heritage of the Native Americans is subject to different interpretations beyond the actual meanings as understood by the natives. The Crow tribe’s names, visions, and imageries are not spared from these relative interpretations. It is claimed that these names, visions, and imageries denote exaggerations, triumphalism, or cultural symbolism. Also, their name can visually reveal the true meanings of descriptive language and metaphors or similes in words and expressions.   The objective of this writing is to examine these names and imageries to differentiate the Europeans’ interpretations of the names and lifestyle of the Cr...